The HOA Covenant Playbook: From Recording to Enforcement
ccrshoa-covenantshoa-governing-documentshoa-boardhoa-enforcement

The HOA Covenant Playbook: From Recording to Enforcement

A staged playbook for HOA boards working with their covenants, conditions and restrictions, from finding the recorded declaration to enforcing it evenly and amending it when it stops fitting.

Doug WrightCites 2 sources

Most HOA boards inherit a stack of paper and a few habits. At the center of that stack sits the declaration of covenants, conditions and restrictions, often shortened to CC&Rs. It's the reason the association can ask an owner to move a shed or repaint a front door.

This playbook takes a board from finding that declaration to enforcing it and, when a covenant stops fitting the community, changing it. The articles a declaration usually contains, from use to assessments, are explained in what your CC&Rs cover. The stages below deal with why the declaration binds owners and what it attaches to.

1. Find the recorded covenants, conditions and restrictions

Start at the county land records for the county where the community sits; in most communities, that's where the declaration was recorded, and anyone can look it up there. Amendments are usually recorded too, each as its own document, so a complete set is the original declaration plus every amendment filed after it.

Hands sorting documents in an open file folder on a table

Photo by Anete Lusina on Pexels

Pull the recorded copies even if the board already keeps a binder. A binder copy may be a draft, may be missing an amendment, or may mix in rules that were never recorded.

2. Know why the declaration binds owners who never signed it

Most owners never signed the declaration. They bought a lot that was already subject to it. Under general property law, a real covenant runs with the land, which means the obligation passes to each later owner along with the property. A covenant has to exist in writing, either in its own instrument or in a deed, and the same page notes that "Homeowners' associations are some of the most common covenant enforcers."

Courts have also traditionally treated restrictions like these as equitable servitudes. An equitable servitude is a restriction on land that a court will enforce against a later owner who took the land with notice of it, usually through an injunction, which is a court order to stop doing something or to do it. The longer post on what an equitable servitude is and how it binds every owner goes further.

California writes the idea into its statute. California Civil Code 5975 says the covenants and restrictions in the declaration are enforceable equitable servitudes, "unless unreasonable", that benefit and bind all owners of separate interests in the development. (A separate interest is the lot or unit an owner holds.) Unless the declaration states otherwise, any owner, the association, or both can enforce them. FindLaw notes its code pages may not reflect the latest law, so check the current text. Check your own declaration and your state's statute for how this works where you are.

3. Sort what is recorded from what isn't

Recording is generally what puts later buyers on notice. Constructive notice is the legal idea that the law treats a person as knowing about a document, such as a recorded declaration, once the required procedure has been followed, even if they never read it. In general, that's why an owner's claim that nobody told them about a recorded covenant rarely gets far. The post on constructive notice and recorded CC&Rs explains how it works.

Bylaws, rules and architectural guidelines are often not recorded, and whether that matters depends on the declaration and your state's law. California's statute, for example, treats governing documents other than the declaration differently: the association can enforce them against an owner, and an owner can enforce them against the association. For anything unrecorded, hand owners and buyers a copy directly, in the resale package and the welcome packet, and adopt each rule the way the declaration allows.

4. Map what the association owns and the easements

Next, work out what land the association owns or maintains. Depending on the documents and the state, this is called common area or common elements, such as the pond, the entrance or the walking path. Some documents also set aside limited common elements, areas reserved for one or some owners. The plat, which is the recorded map of the subdivision, and the declaration's maintenance article draw the line, and common area and common elements walks through how to read them.

Then list the easements. An easement is a right to use someone else's land for a specific purpose, such as a utility line along the back of a lot or a drainage path between two homes. Many declarations and plats set out utility, drainage and access easements, and those can limit what an owner may build in that strip. The post on easements in an HOA covers who can use, cross or maintain each kind.

5. Handle boundary complaints without taking sides

At some point an owner tells the board that a neighbor's fence sits on their lot. Where the line between two private lots runs is usually a matter for those two owners, their deeds and a survey. The board's part is narrower: a recorded covenant such as a fence setback, the conditions on an approval from the architectural review committee (ARC), or a fence that reaches into common area.

Two dogs resting in a backyard in front of a wooden fence

Photo by Vlad Chetan on Pexels

Tell both owners in writing which questions the board will act on, handle those the same way it would for any other owner, and leave the boundary itself to the two of them. The post on property line disputes between neighbors sets out the options the owners have and where the board fits.

6. Enforce with standing and consistency

Standing is the legal right to bring an enforcement action. The association usually has it under the declaration and state law, and whether an individual owner has it depends on the documents and the state. In California, in an action to enforce the governing documents, the "prevailing party shall be awarded" reasonable attorney's fees and costs.

Consistency matters as much as standing. A covenant the board has enforced against some owners and let slide for others can become hard to enforce at all. Send written notices, offer a hearing where the documents call for one, and keep a record of what the board did and why. The post on who can enforce a covenant covers the board, an individual owner and the cases where neither can. A final demand is the point to bring in the association's attorney.

7. Amend a covenant that no longer fits

Declarations age. A covenant written for the community's first owners may not fit how people live there now. The usual path is an amendment adopted under the declaration's own amendment procedure and then recorded. The guide on how to amend your HOA's CC&Rs goes through the steps.

The document set every stage runs on

Every stage runs on the same few documents. Keep the recorded declaration, each amendment and the plat together, and note which ones replaced older versions.

A board working through these stages keeps the set in HOA-OS: the recorded declaration, each amendment, the bylaws, the rules and the plat, every file tagged by the board and findable by title in the search box. A document that replaces an older version goes in marked as its replacement, and the superseded copy sits behind "Show replaced documents".

Sources

Related Reading

A board with nothing organized can start at the county land records, with a copy of the recorded declaration and of each amendment filed after it.