PayHOA alternatives for self-managed HOA boards

PayHOA prices in nine bands by unit count, so the bill steps up seven times between a 25-home community and a 500-home one, and its Gable AI assistant adds half the plan price once its three free months end. Here are the PayHOA alternatives a self-managed board shortlists, what each one costs, which ones include AI, and where PayHOA is still the better pick.

What the same community pays

Take a 150-home association. On PayHOA's yearly billing it sits in the 101 to 150 band at $129 a month, and $193.50 once Gable starts billing after three free months. On HOA-OS it pays $89 a month on Premium, with the resident assistant, AI budget drafting and the daily agent included, or $49 on Community, and annual billing takes 15 percent off either. HOA-OS Premium costs $1,254 a year less than PayHOA with Gable, and $480 less with Gable switched off. The gap doesn't close as the community grows, because HOA-OS prices per community: the same $89 covers 150 homes or 900. PayHOA figures checked October 27, 2026.

The head-to-head detail, feature by feature, is on our HOA-OS vs PayHOA comparison page, and the wider field is in our buyer's guide for self-managed boards.

Where PayHOA is the better pick

A community of 25 homes or fewer that wants accounting in the base price.

At that size both are $49 a month, PayHOA on yearly billing, and the PayHOA $49 includes the general ledger and bank reconciliation that HOA-OS carries on Premium at $89. Even with Gable billing, PayHOA is $73.50 at that size against $89. Checked October 27, 2026.

A board that wants someone else to keep the books.

PayHOA sells bookkeeping as a service from $199 a month, an 1120-H filing from $399 and a full 1120 from $995, checked October 27, 2026. HOA-OS gives the board the ledger and the reports and doesn't do the bookkeeping for it.

A community whose dues arrive mostly on cards.

PayHOA's 3.5% plus 50 cents beats the HOA-OS all-in card rate on any payment above $50, which covers most monthly dues. On ACH the order reverses below about $181 a payment.

A board that won't be the first customer of a newer company.

PayHOA has years of operating history. HOA-OS launched in 2026 and has no published third-party reviews yet.

Frequently asked questions

Updated October 27, 2026

What are the best PayHOA alternatives for a self-managed HOA board?
A self-managed board comparing PayHOA alternatives usually shortlists HOA-OS, EasyHOA, RunHOA, HOA Start and TownSq. RunHOA has the lowest published price of the full-featured options at $399 a year flat for unlimited units. EasyHOA prices by unit count from $49 a month for 25 units or fewer, with accounting in every plan. HOA Start quotes on community size and bills annually. TownSq prices per community from $90 a month and, on its Pro plan, includes a website and sells violations tracking, architectural review and its AI as add-ons. HOA-OS prices per community at $49 on Community or $89 on Premium at any size, and its AI is in that price: it builds and hosts the community website and drafts the newsletter for the board to approve. Prices checked October 27, 2026.
Which PayHOA alternative costs the least?
RunHOA has the lowest published price of the full-featured options, $399 a year flat for unlimited units. At 25 units and below the field converges: HOA-OS Community is $49 a month, PayHOA is $49 on yearly billing against $54 month to month, and EasyHOA is $49. What separates them at that size is what the $49 buys, because the EasyHOA and PayHOA price carries full accounting, where HOA-OS keeps its general ledger, bank reconciliation and reserve tracking on Premium at $89. The order changes as the community grows: PayHOA passes HOA-OS Premium at 51 units, EasyHOA matches it at 51 to 100 and passes it at 101, and HOA-OS doesn't move. Prices checked October 27, 2026.
What does PayHOA cost as a community grows?
PayHOA prices across nine bands by unit count. On yearly billing the bands run $49 a month for up to 25 units, $59 at 26 to 50, $99 at 51 to 100, $129 at 101 to 150, $169 at 151 to 200, $199 at 201 to 300, $229 at 301 to 400 and $249 at 401 to 500, and above 500 units a self-managed community pays $0.55 per unit per month. Month to month runs about 10 percent higher. Gable, PayHOA's AI assistant, is switched on by default, free for three months, and then adds half the plan price, $64.50 a month at 101 to 150 units on yearly billing. Checked on payhoa.com/pricing October 27, 2026.
Does PayHOA have AI?
PayHOA sells an AI assistant called Gable, switched on by default for new accounts, free for the first three months, and then billed at half the plan price: for example, $64.50 a month on top of $129 for a 101 to 150 unit community on yearly billing. PayHOA describes it as answering questions from the community's documents and records with sources, taking on tasks such as letters, budgets, bid comparisons and board decks, triaging requests, coding bank transactions and answering homeowners around the clock. TownSq sells suggested replies and request interception as a $20 monthly add-on per community on its up-to-300-unit plans. RunHOA's and EasyHOA's pricing pages list no AI features. HOA-OS keeps its AI in the subscription: the website builder and newsletter drafting on Community, and on Premium a 24/7 resident assistant that answers from the community's own governing documents and an autonomous agent that reviews overdue dues, stalled violations and pending requests each morning and surfaces recommended actions for the board. Checked October 27, 2026.
Can a board move its data off PayHOA?
A board leaving PayHOA can bring the records HOA-OS runs on into HOA-OS: members, vendors and opening balances on Community, plus income and expense categories on Premium, from CSV or Excel, and HOA-OS takes a QuickBooks export directly. Payment history, violation records and stored documents aren't part of that import, so a board that wants them keeps its PayHOA export. The HOA-OS trial runs 30 days on the plan the board picks and takes no credit card. HOA-OS board admins can download the community's records, including messages and newsletters, at any time as one ZIP file of spreadsheet (CSV) and JSON files (a standard format other software can read). The HOA-OS export lists the community's stored documents and photos, with download links that stop working after 7 days. The export leaves out AI assistant conversations and system data such as bank connection internals and board member access levels. After canceling, HOA-OS board admins can still download a fresh export for 30 days.
What do these platforms charge in payment fees?
PayHOA publishes $2.45 per incoming ACH payment and 3.5% plus 50 cents per card payment, and the community chooses whether it or the homeowner pays them. HOA-OS charges a 1% platform fee on cards or $1 flat on ACH, with standard Stripe processing on top at 2.9% plus 30 cents for cards and 0.8% capped at $5 for ACH. Which one costs less depends on the payment method and the size of the payment. On ACH, HOA-OS costs less below about $181 a payment and PayHOA's flat $2.45 costs less above it. On cards, PayHOA costs less on any payment above $50. TownSq and EasyHOA publish no payment processing rate. Checked October 27, 2026. Run your own average payment against both.

Read the full buyer's guide: best HOA software for self-managed boards →

Switching is straightforward

Import your roster from a spreadsheet, and AI drafts the first version of your site, budget and newsletter. Try HOA-OS free for 30 days and run it alongside what you have before you decide.

See full HOA-OS pricing → · HOA-OS vs PayHOA · HOA-OS vs TownSq · HOA-OS vs EasyHOA · Software built for self-managed boards · AI software for HOA management