Property Line Disputes Between Neighbors: Where the HOA Fits
property-line-disputeshoa-fencesencroachmentadverse-possessionhoa-board

Property Line Disputes Between Neighbors: Where the HOA Fits

When two neighbors argue over a fence or a lot line, the board's role is narrower than most owners expect. Here's what the association can act on and what stays between the owners.

Doug WrightCites 2 sources

A fence goes up between two backyards, and the owner next door says it's on their side of the line. Then someone emails the board. Property line disputes with neighbors reach HOA boards often, and the first question is whether the association has any part in the argument at all.

Usually the answer splits in two. The association can act on what its own documents control: a recorded covenant such as a fence setback, the conditions of an architectural approval, or an encroachment onto common area. Where the boundary between two privately owned lots runs is a matter for those two owners, their deeds and a surveyor.

The declaration generally binds every owner because its covenants attach to the land, which is the idea behind an equitable servitude. The board's authority over a line between two lots goes only as far as those covenants do.

Why fences start so many boundary arguments

Confusion over where one lot ends and the next begins is the basis of many disputes between neighbors, according to FindLaw's property boundaries FAQ. The same page names the usual cause: "Property lines are often assumed to be consistent with existing fences or landscape boundaries."

A fence a previous owner built can look like the boundary to everyone on the street. Whether it actually sits on the line is a question for a survey.

When a fence does sit on the line, FindLaw says owners on both sides are responsible for its upkeep, with state law setting the details. The association usually comes into it only if the declaration assigns fence maintenance somewhere else.

A homeowner working in a garden bed along a weathered wooden fence

Photo by Troy Tumbin on Pexels

The survey, the deed and the plat

A deed is the document that transfers ownership of a lot, and it describes the property being conveyed. A plat is a recorded map of the subdivision showing each lot's boundaries; FindLaw notes it also shows the parcel number. Some counties also keep a GIS map, a digital map of parcels.

FindLaw cautions that several documents on file can show different lines for the same lot. Surveyors establish boundary lines with measured angles and distances, and a licensed surveyor can mark the boundaries on the ground. Markers an owner sets on their own may lack legal standing.

For a board, the survey and the deed belong to the owners. The association usually doesn't commission a survey of a private lot, and it can't change what an owner's deed says.

What the HOA can act on in property line disputes

The association's authority comes from the declaration, the recorded document that sets out the community's covenants, and from state law. Our guide to what a declaration usually contains lays out its articles.

Fence setbacks come up often. A setback is a required distance between a structure and a street, a sidewalk or a lot line, and many declarations and architectural guidelines set one for fences. If a fence breaks a setback the documents set, that's a covenant issue the board can take up. Where the setback is measured from a lot line, the board may need the owner's survey to apply it.

ARC approvals matter too. The architectural review committee (ARC) is the group that reviews owners' requests to build or change things on their lots. Its approval may have come with conditions, such as a location, a height or a material. A fence built somewhere other than the approved spot is an ARC matter, and handling work done without approval follows the same steps as any other unapproved change.

Then there's common area. An encroachment is a structure or use that extends onto land its owner doesn't own. When a fence, shed or garden bed crosses onto common area, the association is the neighbor in the dispute, and the board speaks for it.

What stays between the owners is where the line between two private lots runs and whose survey is right.

Why an encroachment onto common area shouldn't sit for years

FindLaw notes that many states let a person who uses another's land long enough gain legal rights to it. The doctrine is called adverse possession, and it's the main reason a board shouldn't let an encroachment onto common area go unaddressed.

Cornell's Legal Information Institute explains adverse possession as a way a trespasser who physically occupies land owned by someone else may acquire valid title, if state requirements are met and the possession lasts long enough. The use generally has to be continuous, actual and exclusive. It also has to be open and notorious, meaning obvious enough to put the true owner on notice.

It must also be hostile, which in this setting means the use infringes on the true owner's rights, however cordial the neighbors are. Cornell notes that permission from the owner defeats this element.

A grassy strip running between a wooden fence and the side of a house

Photo by Alfo Medeiros on Pexels

Cornell gives California's period as five years and New York's as 10, and adds: "The threshold, however, varies by jurisdiction." Whether a claim like this could succeed against common area depends on your state's law and the facts. Still, an encroachment the board knows about and leaves alone for years fits the pattern the doctrine describes.

The board's options usually include a written request to remove the encroachment or a written permission that sets terms. Before the board picks one, give the association's attorney the facts and the declaration's common-area article.

What grandfathered means for an old fence

An owner with an old fence on the line may ask whether a grandfather clause covers it. In HOA terms, grandfathered describes a structure that predates a rule and may be allowed to stay under it. Whether that applies depends on the declaration's wording and how the rule was adopted. Our post on what a grandfather clause protects goes through the details.

That protection applies to the association's rule. The deeds and the survey still decide where the boundary between the two lots runs.

If the board treats one older fence as grandfathered, similar fences in similar situations should get the same answer.

Staying neutral when neighbors dispute a boundary

When two owners argue over where their shared line runs, the board can share what its own records show about the fence, say plainly which parts it can act on, and leave the location of the line itself to the two owners.

FindLaw lists the paths the neighbors have. They can negotiate, including through mediation, where a neutral person helps both sides reach an agreement. They can settle on a line together; as FindLaw puts it, "Property lines can be changed through mutual agreement," by signing a new deed that describes the line and filing it in the county land records. Mortgage approval and local zoning rules may apply to that step.

If talks fail, either owner can file a legal claim to quiet title or re-establish the boundary. A quiet title action asks a court to decide who owns the disputed strip of land.

Once the owners settle the line, the board can apply its setback and ARC conditions to the result.

The records behind a fence complaint

When a fence complaint comes in, the board needs the declaration and any amendments, the recorded plat, the architectural guidelines, and the ARC file for that fence.

Each unit's page in HOA-OS shows that lot's violation history and its property transfer history. The committee reviews each fence request in the ARC workflow, and the board uploads the rules and the recorded plat to the document library with a visibility setting on each.

Sources

Related Reading

By keeping to its own covenants, ARC approvals and common area, the board avoids taking a side in a boundary fight that only the owners' deeds, a survey or a court can settle.