Electronic Signatures on HOA Forms and Agreements
hoa-electronic-signaturee-signaturesuetaarc-requestshoa-records

Electronic Signatures on HOA Forms and Agreements

When an HOA electronic signature counts on ARC applications, payment authorizations and vendor agreements, and what a signed record needs to show so the board can rely on it later.

Doug WrightCites 2 sources

An owner emails back an architectural change request with a typed name in the signature box. A landscaper returns the board's contract with a signature drawn on a phone screen. Either one can be an HOA electronic signature that counts, and either one can turn into an argument later if nobody can show who signed and what they signed.

Electronic-transactions laws keep a signature from being rejected only because it's electronic. They don't decide whether a particular signature is good, and they don't replace the association's declaration (the recorded document that sets the community's covenants) and bylaws. Background is in our overview of UETA and when electronic records and signatures count.

What counts as an HOA electronic signature

The Uniform Electronic Transactions Act, or UETA, is a uniform law that states adopt, each in its own form. The version quoted here is Florida's, section 668.50 of the Florida Statutes. Other states' versions can differ, so read your own state's text.

Florida's text defines an electronic signature as "an electronic sound, symbol, or process attached to or logically associated with a record and executed or adopted by a person with the intent to sign the record." A record, in plain terms, is the document or data being signed. The definition is broad, and the deciding questions are whether the mark or process is tied to the record and whether the person adopted it with the intent to sign.

Section 668.50(7)(a) says "A record or signature may not be denied legal effect or enforceability solely because the record or signature is in electronic form." Paragraph (7)(d) adds: "If a provision of law requires a signature, an electronic signature satisfies such provision." The word "solely" carries the weight. The electronic format stops being an objection, and the other questions about the signature stay open.

Florida's version also "applies only to transactions between parties each of which has agreed to conduct transactions by electronic means." Whether they agreed "is determined from the context and surrounding circumstances, including the parties' conduct." The act doesn't require anyone to use electronic records, and under (5)(c) a party that agreed to one electronic transaction "may refuse to conduct other transactions by electronic means."

Attribution means tying a signature to the person who made it. Under (9)(a), an electronic signature is attributable to a person "if the record or signature was the act of the person." That act "may be shown in any manner, including a showing of the efficacy of any security procedure applied to determine the person to which the electronic record or electronic signature was attributable." A security procedure is a step designed to confirm who is signing. Paragraph (9)(b) says the effect of the signature "is determined from the context and surrounding circumstances at the time of its creation, execution, or adoption, including the parties' agreement, if any, and otherwise as provided by law."

The federal E-SIGN rule

The federal Electronic Signatures in Global and National Commerce Act, usually called E-SIGN, reaches transactions "in or affecting interstate or foreign commerce," meaning business that crosses or affects state or national lines. For those transactions, the general rule of validity in 15 U.S.C. 7001 says "a signature, contract, or other record relating to such transaction may not be denied legal effect, validity, or enforceability solely because it is in electronic form."

Like Florida's text, the federal rule turns on the word "solely." Neither law makes a particular architectural approval or vendor contract valid.

What these laws leave to the association

The declaration, the bylaws and the state's HOA statute still set the association's own rules on signatures, approvals and votes. The electronic-transactions laws don't override those rules. If the declaration or bylaws call for a signature in a particular form, that requirement still applies.

Other law can apply too. Florida's section 668.50(3)(e) says "A transaction subject to this section is also subject to other applicable provisions of substantive law." Statutes change as well, and the current text of your own state's law controls.

Where boards collect e-signatures

One common place for an electronic signature is the architectural review (ARC) application, where an owner asks to change the exterior of a home. When the form asks the owner to sign, the signature ties the owner to the plans and conditions on that version of the form. What goes in an HOA ARC application covers the rest of the form.

Payment authorizations come up too. An owner who signs up to pay assessments from a bank account signs a document that other law, and the payment provider's own terms, may also govern.

A woman signing on a tablet with a stylus while seated at home

Photo by Berna on Pexels

With vendor agreements, the board is the signer. Landscapers, pool services and other contractors often send contracts through their own e-signature platform. Check the bylaws for which officers can sign on the association's behalf, and confirm the board approved the contract before anyone signs it.

If owners sign online, a single request form on the community website keeps those signatures in one place. Boards that want one can put a request form on the website without writing code.

What makes a signed record usable later

A usable signed record shows:

  • who signed, and how that person was identified (the account, email address or phone number used)
  • what they signed, meaning the final version with any plans or attachments
  • when they signed
  • that the record can still be found and opened

Florida's retention paragraph, (12)(a), describes the standard for keeping an electronic record where a law requires a record be retained. The electronic record "Accurately reflects the information set forth in the record after the record was first generated in final form as an electronic record or otherwise" and "Remains accessible for later reference."

In practice, save the signed final copy as a file nobody edits afterward. If an owner changes the plans after signing, get a new signature on the new version. An approval tied to a draft the owner later revised is hard to rely on.

Notarization, wet ink and recorded documents

Notarization means a notary public confirms the identity of the person signing. A wet-ink signature is pen on paper. Read the declaration and bylaws for any requirement of either one, and note which actions it covers.

Documents the association records with the county are a separate question. Have the association's attorney confirm how e-signatures apply in your state and under your documents, and ask before relying on an electronic signature for anything that will be recorded.

A hand signing a paper document with a pen at a wooden table

Photo by Vidal Balielo Jr. on Pexels

Some owners won't want to sign online. Florida's text doesn't require anyone to use electronic records, so keep a paper version of each form and accept it on the same terms.

Keeping signed forms with the request

File each signed document with the thing it belongs to. A signed ARC application goes with the plans, the committee's decision and any conditions. A signed vendor contract goes with the minutes or vote that approved it. When a new board member asks what was agreed, the answer sits in one folder.

HOA-OS has a form builder with 14 field types, including Signature and File Upload, and a submissions inbox where the board reviews and routes every submission. ARC requests move through their own architectural review workflow, and a signed vendor contract can go into document storage marked visible to the board only.

Sources

Related Reading

Keeping each signature with the exact document it signed spares the board from piecing together, long after the fact, who agreed to what from a trail of forwarded emails.