Online Voting in an HOA
hoa-online-votingelectronic-votingsecret-ballothoa-electionshoa-records

Online Voting in an HOA

When an HOA can use electronic ballots, how secret ballots and paper alternatives fit in, and what record of the results a board keeps, with Virginia and Florida as worked examples.

Doug WrightCites 3 sources

HOA online voting lets owners cast a ballot from a laptop or a phone, and for a self-managed board it can mean fewer envelopes to stuff, chase and count. Whether your association can use it, and on what conditions, depends on your governing documents and your state's HOA statute. Some statutes speak to electronic voting directly.

Voting raises its own questions: when electronic ballots are allowed, how a secret ballot stays secret, how the board knows each ballot came from an owner entitled to cast it, and what record of the results the board keeps afterward. General laws on when electronic records and signatures count leave the association's own statute and documents to set the rules for notice, ballots and meetings.

What decides whether your HOA can vote online

Your governing documents come first. The declaration (the recorded document that creates the association and binds the lots, often called the CC&Rs) and the bylaws (the rules for how the association runs its meetings and elections) may say how ballots are cast, who counts them and how notice of a vote goes out.

Your state's HOA statute sits on top of those documents. Some statutes allow electronic voting unless the declaration expressly prohibits it. Others attach conditions, such as guidelines the board adopts first or a paper ballot for owners who want one. Statutes change, too, and the current text on your state legislature's website controls over any summary, this one included.

HOA online voting under Virginia's statute

Virginia's Property Owners Association Act has a section on technology. Virginia Code section 55.1-1832 opens subsection (A) with "Unless expressly prohibited by the declaration," and goes on to allow any signature, vote, consent or approval required under the declaration, the bylaws or that chapter to be accomplished using electronic means. In plain English, the electronic option is available unless the declaration expressly rules it out.

Subsection (D) adds a condition for votes. Electronic voting is allowed "provided that a record is created as evidence of such vote, consent, or approval and maintained as long as such record would be required to be maintained in nonelectronic form." The electronic record of a vote has to be kept for as long as a paper record of the same vote would have been.

A separate section on association meetings, Virginia Code section 55.1-1815, covers votes at a meeting. Subsection (H) says, "Unless expressly prohibited by the governing documents, a member may vote at a meeting of the association in person, by proxy, or by absentee ballot." A proxy is a written authorization for someone else to vote on your behalf. An absentee ballot is one you cast yourself without attending. The same subsection says such voting "may take place by electronic means, provided that the board of directors has adopted guidelines for such voting by electronic means."

Subsection (H) also says members voting by absentee ballot or proxy "shall be deemed to be present at the meeting for all purposes." For more on both methods, see HOA proxy votes and absentee ballots, explained.

For a Virginia board, that means board-adopted guidelines before electronic voting at a meeting, and a record of each electronic vote.

A woman using a laptop at her kitchen counter with her dog beside her

Photo by RDNE Stock project on Pexels

Secret ballots and owners who want paper

A secret ballot is a vote where no one, the board included, can match a ballot to the person who cast it. Your governing documents or your statute may require one for some votes.

Virginia's subsection (D) addresses this directly: "If the vote, consent, or approval is required to be obtained by secret ballot, the electronic means shall protect the identity of the voter. If the electronic means cannot protect the identity of the voter, another means of voting shall be used."

That gives a board a practical question to ask of any voting tool. Who can see the link between a voter and a choice? If an administrator can see how each owner voted, find out whether that meets your secret-ballot requirement, and have a paper ballot ready for the votes that need one.

Virginia also covers owners who'd prefer not to go online. Under subsection (G), "If any person does not have the capability or desire to conduct business using electronic means, the association shall make available a reasonable alternative, at its expense, for such person to conduct business with the association without use of such electronic means." The statute doesn't specify the alternative. A mailed paper ballot is one option a board might choose.

What Florida's statute says about votes and voting records

Two provisions of Florida's homeowners' association statute bear on this topic. Section 720.303 of the Florida Statutes says in subsection (2)(a) that members of the board "may use e-mail as a means of communication but may not cast a vote on an association matter via e-mail."

The same section lists the official records an association keeps. Subsection (4)(a)12. covers "Ballots, sign-in sheets, voting proxies, and all other papers and electronic records relating to voting by parcel owners, which must be maintained for at least 1 year after the date of the election, vote, or meeting." On a plain reading, that language reaches the electronic records an online vote produces, and a Florida board would keep them for at least 1 year after the vote.

A woman filing folders into a document box at home

Photo by RDNE Stock project on Pexels

Those two provisions don't answer whether Florida owners may cast ballots online in a member vote. For that, look to your governing documents and the full current statute.

Questions to settle before an online vote

A board can work through these before the first electronic ballot goes out:

  • Does the declaration or the bylaws expressly prohibit electronic voting, or name a required method such as mailed ballots?
  • Does your state's statute ask for anything first, such as guidelines adopted by the board?
  • Which owners get a paper ballot, and how does an owner ask for one?
  • How will the board confirm that each electronic ballot came from an owner entitled to vote, and that each owner voted once?
  • If the vote is by secret ballot, who can see the link between a voter and a choice?
  • Where will the results record live, and for how long?

Settle how quorum (the minimum participation your governing documents or statute require for a vote to count) is tallied for online ballots, too. Our walkthrough on running a vote and tracking quorum covers those mechanics.

Have the association's attorney confirm how these rules apply in your state and under your documents before relying on an online ballot for an election or an amendment.

Keeping a record of the results

The record is what lets the board answer questions after the vote closes: who could vote, who did, whether quorum was met, what the outcome was and when the vote was open. Virginia ties electronic voting to that record, and Florida sets a minimum keeping period for voting records. Store the results with the board's other official records, and keep any paper ballots next to the electronic results when a vote used both.

HOA-OS runs board votes and community ballots with a quorum percentage the board sets, Yes/No/Abstain choices and an optional anonymous-ballot setting, and each closed vote shows participation, whether quorum was met, the outcome and the dates it was open. Each resident record shows whether that owner opted in or out of electronic contact.

Sources

Related Reading

Does your declaration expressly prohibit voting by electronic means, and what does your state's current HOA statute ask of the board before an electronic ballot counts?